Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Red-capped mushrooms: edible and dangerous

By Valeriia·Updated ·7 min read

A red cap says nothing about edibility: the red-capped scaber stalk is an excellent edible, the fly agaric is poisonous. The stem, flesh and base tell them apart.

The sickener (Russula emetica): a pinkish-red cap on a white stem in green moss
Photo: Jason Hollinger · CC BY 2.0 · source

Red-topped mushrooms and red toadstools are not all poisonous, but the commonest ones are. The fly agaric is poisonous and the sickener causes several days of vomiting, while the orange and brick-red Leccinum boletes (the red-capped scaber stalks) are good edibles. A red cap on its own tells you nothing. What matters is what is under the cap, the stem and flesh, and whether there's a skirt or sac at the base.

Let's go through the main red-capped mushrooms: which are edible, which are dangerous, and how to keep them apart.

Common red mushrooms

The red-capped mushrooms you are most likely to find are the fly agaric, the sickener and the orange-capped Leccinum boletes. All three grow in woodland, always next to particular trees, so the trees are your first clue.

The fly agaric grows with birch, pine and spruce from late summer to late autumn. Its white spots can wash off in rain, so a plain red cap with white gills, a hanging white ring and a swollen base is still a fly agaric. The sickener is a red brittlegill of conifer woods and wet, mossy heath, out from late summer to autumn, with a scarlet cap over pure white gills and stem.

The orange birch bolete grows only under birch, from summer to early autumn, and has an orange cap and a stem covered in blackish scales. Its relative, the red-capped scaber stalk (Leccinum aurantiacum), has a brick-red cap and reddish-brown scales on the stem. It appears mostly under poplar and aspen, sometimes under oak, beech or birch, from summer to late autumn. Both have a sponge of pores under the cap, not gills.

Red mushroom names: start with where it grows

You can usually name a bright red mushroom by where it is growing: in grass, on a tree trunk, on mossy twigs or on the woodland floor. Each place has its own short list.

A small, shiny, bright red mushroom in a mown lawn, an old churchyard or short grassland in autumn is most likely a waxcap. The scarlet waxcap is the one found most often, in autumn. Its cap starts blood red and fades to orange and yellow from the edge. Waxcaps are not worth picking to eat.

A red, liver-shaped bracket low on the trunk of an oak or sweet chestnut from summer to autumn is the beefsteak fungus. It 'bleeds' red when cut and is edible only when young. Small scarlet cups on fallen, moss-covered twigs in damp woods are scarlet elfcups, which turn up mostly in the colder months, from late autumn into spring.

If everything is red, cap, gills and stem, and you are in a dark, mossy conifer wood, think of the bloodred webcap. It is treated as suspect and should never be gathered, because some related reddish webcaps are deadly poisonous.

Edible mushrooms with a red cap

Several prized mushrooms are reddish or orange-red.

  • Red-capped scaber stalk. Also known as the redcap. A brick-red or orange cap and a firm stem with dark scales. It's an excellent edible bolete, but cook it well, for at least 15 minutes: raw or undercooked, Leccinum boletes can upset the stomach. The white flesh darkens to violet-grey or almost black when cut, and the stem base often turns blue-green. It grows mainly under oak, poplar and aspen.
  • Reddish brittlegills. Many brittlegills have red tones, and some of them are edible. But red species are hard to tell apart, and the poisonous sickener is red too, so beginners are better off leaving bright red brittlegills in the wood.

No single feature proves a mushroom edible. The edible red-capped species have no skirt and no sac at the base, but neither does the poisonous sickener, so only the full set of features for the species counts.

Poisonous mushrooms with a red cap

Bright red mushrooms are the ones that most often make people wary, and with good reason.

  • Fly agaric. The best-known poisonous mushroom: a bright red cap with white spots, a skirt and a swollen base. Here the colour really is a warning.
  • Sickener. A bright red, acrid brittlegill with a burning taste. It causes digestive upset.
  • Devil's bolete. A bolete with a pale, off-white cap: the red is on the pores and stem, not the cap, and it turns blue when cut. Poisonous, though not deadly.
Closer view of a fly agaric (Amanita muscaria) in a sunny pine wood: a bright red cap with a few white dots, moss behind
That bright red is a warning: the fly agaric is poisonous and never goes in the basket. September 2026. · Photo:

As you can see, red caps cover both bright poisonous amanitas and treacherous brittlegills. Colour is only a reason to take a closer look.

Red pores, not a red cap: the devil's bolete

The devil's bolete does not have a red cap: its cap is chalky white at first, later with an olive or slightly reddish tinge. The red is on the pores and on the stem, which has a red net pattern, and the flesh turns pale blue when cut.

It is found mainly on chalk and limestone under mature oak and beech in late summer and autumn. It is seriously poisonous, raw or cooked, so never eat a bolete with red pores unless an expert has confirmed the species.

How to tell them apart

To avoid mistakes with a red-capped mushroom, go through the features one by one.

  1. Look under the cap. Pores (a sponge) mean a bolete, such as the red-capped scaber stalk or the devil's bolete. Gills mean an amanita or a brittlegill.
  2. Check the stem. A skirt plus a sac at the base marks an amanita. Scales on the stem point to the red-capped scaber stalk.
  3. Don't sort brittlegills by taste. A red brittlegill can be edible or poisonous, and the species differ in fine details. Never taste a mushroom to identify it, and take only species you can name for certain.
  4. Look at the cut. If a bolete with red pores turns blue, be wary: it could be the devil's bolete.

Red-capped mushrooms are a good illustration of the main rule: colour doesn't determine edibility. You'll find more red mushrooms in our collection by cap colour, and general guidance in the rules for safe foraging.

Red brittlegills: the sickener and the beechwood sickener

Red brittlegills are hard to tell apart even for experts, so as a beginner you are safer leaving all bright red ones in the wood. The sickener has a scarlet cap that fades in wet weather, with white gills and a white stem. The beechwood sickener looks almost the same and is just as poisonous.

Eating a sickener leads to nausea, vomiting, severe stomach pain and then diarrhoea, and you can feel very poorly for several days. It is unlikely to be fatal, but frail people and very young children are at greater risk. Both species are known for a burning, acrid taste: that is a property recorded in field guides, not a test to try yourself.

If someone has eaten a red mushroom

If someone may have eaten a poisonous mushroom, call 112 (999 in the UK) or your local poison centre straight away, even if they feel well: some dangerous species cause symptoms only hours later. If the person is unconscious, struggling to breathe or having a fit, call 112 (999 in the UK) at once.

Do not try to make them sick, and do not give them anything to eat or drink. Take the rest of the mushroom, or a photo of it, to show the doctors.

Enjoyed the article?

Opens your phone’s share menu: WhatsApp, Messages or any other app.

Mushrooms in this article

Frequently asked questions

Are all mushrooms with a red cap poisonous?

No. Red caps belong to the tasty red-capped scaber stalk and edible brittlegills, but also to the poisonous fly agaric. Colour alone doesn't determine edibility.

Which edible mushroom has a red cap?

Above all the red-capped scaber stalk, or redcap, with its brick-red cap and firm stem covered in dark scales. Some reddish brittlegills are edible too, but red species are hard to tell apart, so leave them to experienced foragers.

How do you tell a red-capped scaber stalk from a fly agaric?

The red-capped scaber stalk has pores underneath, a scaly stem, and no skirt or sac. The fly agaric has gills, a white skirt, a swollen base and white spots on the cap.

Why is the fly agaric so easy to spot?

Its bright red cap with white spots is easy to remember. But rain can wash the spots off, so a plain red cap with white gills, a ring and a swollen base can still be a fly agaric.

Are red brittlegills edible?

Some are, some aren't. Many red brittlegills are acrid and bitter, like the sickener. That's why beginners are better off avoiding the bright red ones and never tasting them to check.

What is the devil's bolete?

The devil's bolete is a poisonous bolete with reddish pores and a stem that turns blue when cut. It isn't deadly, but it causes digestive upset, so don't pick it.

Can you trust a mushroom's colour?

No. Colour is an unreliable signal: the deadly death cap is pale and unremarkable, while the poisonous fly agaric is bright. Always check the other features, not just the colour.

Where do you start identifying a red-capped mushroom?

Look under the cap first: pores point to a bolete, gills to an amanita or a brittlegill. Then check the stem and the base. Taste is not a test: never put a mushroom in your mouth to identify it.

Related articles