Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Horse mushroom or Agaricus comtulus

How they differ, how to recognize them and which is more dangerous — a mushroom comparison

The short answer

Horse mushroom and Agaricus comtulus are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: season: Horse mushroom — summer, autumn, Agaricus comtulus — spring, summer, autumn. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: use, size, cap color.

Horse mushroom (Agaricus arvensis)

Horse mushroom

Agaricus arvensis

EdibleExpert-verified
Agaricus comtulus (Agaricus comtulus)

Agaricus comtulus

Agaricus comtulus

EdibleNot reviewed by an editor

📊 Comparing characteristics

Comparison of characteristics: Horse mushroom and Agaricus comtulus
Edibility class

Horse mushroom

Edible

Agaricus comtulus

Edible
Season

Horse mushroom

SummerAutumn

Agaricus comtulus

SpringSummerAutumn
Use

Horse mushroom

Cook freshDryingPickling

Agaricus comtulus

Cook fresh
Size

Horse mushroom

Large (over 15 cm)

Agaricus comtulus

Small (up to 5 cm)
Cap color

Horse mushroom

WhiteCream

Agaricus comtulus

WhiteCreamGrey
Cap shape

Horse mushroom

Convex

Agaricus comtulus

ConvexFlat
Cap surface

Horse mushroom

Smooth

Agaricus comtulus

SmoothFibrous
Taste

Horse mushroom

Mild

Agaricus comtulus

Mild
Smell

Horse mushroom

PleasantAniseAlmond

Agaricus comtulus

Anise
Flesh color change

Horse mushroom

Yellowing

Agaricus comtulus

Yellowing
Hymenophore

Horse mushroom

Gilled

Agaricus comtulus

Gilled
Stem

Horse mushroom

Central

Agaricus comtulus

Central
Ring (veil)

Horse mushroom

Ring present

Agaricus comtulus

Ring present
Volva

Horse mushroom

No volva

Agaricus comtulus

No volva
Substrate

Horse mushroom

SoilDung

Agaricus comtulus

Soil
Nutrition type

Horse mushroom

Saprotroph

Agaricus comtulus

Saprotroph

📅 Seasonality

Horse mushroom

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

June – November

Agaricus comtulus

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

May – October

🔬 Morphology

Cap

Horse mushroom

Cap 6-20 cm across; in young mushrooms firmly hemispherical to egg-shaped, the margin often rolled under. Later it becomes convex to flat. Color pure white to cream, with subtle yellowish tints in old mushrooms; spots yellow to ocher when touched. Surface smooth, slightly sticky in wet weather, dry and matte in dry weather. Sometimes with fine fibrous scales in the center.

Agaricus comtulus

The cap of Agaricus comtulus is small — 2 to 5 centimeters across. When young it is hemispherical or convex; with age it opens out flat. The surface is dry, smooth or finely fibrous, white, cream or with a faint grayish-yellowish tint, often darker in the center. It may turn faintly yellow when touched. Its small size and pale coloring give the mushroom a modest, delicate look.

Hymenophore

Horse mushroom

Gilled hymenophore — gills free, crowded. When young — grayish-white, with a pinkish tinge, becoming with age dark brown, chocolate-blackish. Spore print dark brown.

Agaricus comtulus

The spore-bearing surface is made of gills. The gills are free, not attached to the stem, and crowded. Their color changes with age: in young mushrooms they are pale pink or grayish-pink, then darken to brown and blackish-brown. The spore print is dark brown. Pinkish young gills set Agaricus apart from the white-gilled poisonous amanitas.

Stem

Horse mushroom

Stem 6-12 cm tall, 1.5-3 cm thick, thick, fleshy, cylindrical, slightly thickened at the base. Color white to cream. On the upper part — a large membranous double ring with a characteristic "toothed" lower edge (like a cogwheel) — a diagnostic feature of the species.

Agaricus comtulus

The stem is thin, slender, white, 2 to 5 centimeters tall, often with a slightly thickened base. Near the top there is a thin whitish ring — a remnant of the veil — which can be fragile in small mushrooms. There is no volva at the base — an important difference from poisonous amanitas.

Flesh

Horse mushroom

Flesh firm, meaty, white; when cut it slowly yellows in the flesh of the cap and upper stem. Does not redden (unlike A. silvaticus). The smell is a distinct anise-almond — a characteristic feature of the species.

Agaricus comtulus

The flesh is white and thin, and turns faintly yellow or stays unchanged when cut. The taste is mild and pleasant, with a light anise-almond note. Because the flesh is thin and the mushroom small, its culinary value is modest, so it rounds out a basket rather than forming the basis of a dish.

Smell

Horse mushroom

Distinctly anise-almond, fruity — the most characteristic diagnostic sign. It comes out when you rub the flesh between your fingers. This smell is one of the most pleasant mushroom experiences in field foraging.

Agaricus comtulus

The smell is pleasant and faint, with an anise or almond note. If the mushroom smells of ink or carbolic and the flesh turns bright yellow when cut, it may be the poisonous yellow stainer or one of its small relatives, and you must not take it.

📍 Habitats

Horse mushroom

Deciduous forest

Agaricus comtulus

MeadowField

👀 Similar mushrooms — don't mix them up!

❓ Frequently asked questions

Can Horse mushroom and Agaricus comtulus be mixed up?
Yes, they look so similar that people often mix them up. The season, use, size help tell them apart.
How to tell Horse mushroom from Agaricus comtulus?
The main differences: season: Horse mushroom — summer, autumn, Agaricus comtulus — spring, summer, autumn; use: Horse mushroom — cook fresh, drying, pickling, Agaricus comtulus — cook fresh; size: Horse mushroom — large (over 15 cm), Agaricus comtulus — small (up to 5 cm). The full table of characteristics is higher up on this page.
Is Agaricus comtulus edible?
Agaricus comtulus — edible.
When do Horse mushroom and Agaricus comtulus grow?
Horse mushroom — June–November; Agaricus comtulus — May–October.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine