Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: zaca · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source

Poisonous✓ Checked by an expert

Agaricus romagnesii

SeasonJuly – December

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
Brown
Size
Medium (5–15 cm)

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Jul — Dec

Active months: July, August, September, October, November, December.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

Agaricus romagnesii is a fairly recently described European Agaricus (1977), named after the French mycologist Henri Romagnesi. Older literature sometimes filed it under the prince (A. augustus) or other variants. It’s a large, fleshy mushroom with a brownish, scaly cap, much like A. augustus but more subdued in colour and with a weaker anise smell.

Poisonous. It was once called edible and tasty, but the Swiss physician and mycologist René Flammer classes it as toxic, and a poisoning in England was confirmed by DNA. We advise against eating it. As in many scaly woodland Agaricus species, the cut flesh turns pinkish to brownish, but that gives no protection against amanitas: check the gills and the stem base.

Safety is critical. As with other Agaricus mushrooms, the key is to rule out confusion with (1) destroying angels and death caps (white gills and a volva: definitely not this mushroom) and (2) the yellow stainer (inky smell, chrome-yellow stem base). If in doubt, leave it.

In Europe it grows in deciduous forests in the mountains, foothills and lowlands; in Ukraine it’s uncommon but turns up reliably. It’s a saprotroph, living on humus-rich soil among fallen leaves. Season: late summer to autumn. It often grows singly or in small groups of 2-5.

Cap

The cap is 6-15 cm across, hemispherical to egg-shaped when young, later convex to flat. It’s brownish-cream to greyish-brown, with distinct small brown or dark brown scales in the centre and middle zone. The surface is dry, slightly sticky in wet weather.

Hymenophore

The gills are free and crowded, pale pink when young, turning dark brown to chocolate-black with age. Spore print dark brown.

Stem

The stem is 8-12 cm tall and 1-2 cm thick, cylindrical and slightly thickened at the base. It’s white to cream, with fine brownish fibres below the ring. Near the top is a white membranous ring, distinct in young mushrooms.

Flesh

The flesh is firm and white, and when cut it slowly turns pinkish to brownish. It can yellow slightly in the stem, so colour is no reliable test against the yellow stainer. The smell is pleasantly mushroomy, sometimes with a faint carbolic note.

Smell

Pleasantly mushroomy, with a sometimes faint carbolic note. So smell doesn't reliably separate it from the yellow stainer.

Don’t mix them up

Agaricus romagnesii lookalikes and comparison

FeatureAgaricus romagnesiiYellow stainer
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourBrown, CreamWhite, Cream, Yellow
SmellPleasant, AlmondChemical
EdibilityPoisonousPoisonous
Full comparison: Agaricus romagnesii vs Yellow stainer →
Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Agaricus romagnesiichange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to eat?

We advise against it. Older sources list it as edible, but poisonings have been reported: a case in Britain confirmed by DNA and four people taken ill in Tuscany. Its smell and slight yellowing in the stem also mean it can't be reliably told from the yellow stainer.

How do you tell it from its poisonous relatives?

Two key checks. (1) Smell: A. romagnesii smells mostly pleasant, but sometimes faintly carbolic, while the yellow stainer and the inky mushroom smell of ink. (2) Flesh colour when you cut the stem: in A. romagnesii it can yellow slightly before turning pinkish; in the yellow stainer and the inky mushroom it’s bright chrome yellow at the stem base. So for this species neither check is reliable. The most serious danger is confusing it with amanitas (white gills and a volva).

How is it different from the blushing wood mushroom?

They look very alike: both are brownish and scaly. Cut the blushing wood mushroom (A. silvaticus) and its flesh turns STRONGLY red. In Agaricus romagnesii the flesh slowly turns pinkish, much less noticeably. The blushing wood mushroom is edible, but we list A. romagnesii as poisonous, so the difference matters, as does telling both from amanitas.

Where should you look for it?

In deciduous and mixed forests, on humus-rich soil among fallen leaves. It likes shady forest edges and slopes with a thick layer of leaf litter. It’s a saprotroph.

Where in Europe is it found?

Mostly in the forest zone, from mountain and foothill forests to lowland woods. It’s not abundant, and finds are sporadic from year to year.

When should you look for it?

Late summer to autumn, peaking in early autumn, right in the main mushroom season.

What mushrooms is it confused with?

The blushing wood mushroom (A. silvaticus): edible, also scaly, but its flesh reddens more strongly. The prince (A. augustus): edible, a closer relative with a stronger anise smell. Its poisonous yellow-staining relatives: dangerous, so check the smell and the stem.

How do you cook it?

We advise against cooking it: it is poisonous. It used to be cooked like other Agaricus mushrooms: fry it with onions and sour cream, pickle it after boiling for 10 min, or stew it with potatoes. On its own it makes an unremarkable dish; it’s better mixed with porcini and Xerocomus boletes.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Flammer R.: Periskop, Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Pilzkunde 2006, S. 18 (2006)
  • [8]Edwards A., Leech T.: Agaricus bresadolanus, a toxic mushroom. Field Mycology 15 (2014)
  • [9]Parra L.A., Vizzini A., Ercole E., Geml J.: Morphological and phylogenetic studies of Agaricus bresadolanus, Agaricus infidus (nom. inval.) and Agaricus romagnesii (Agaricaceae) reveal their conspecificity and variation in toxicity of this taxon. Phytotaxa 578(3): 241–260 (2023)
  • [10]Flammer R.: Periskop 3 (SZP 2006), Flammer R. (2006)
  • [11]Edwards & Leech: Agaricus bresadolanus, a toxic mushroom (2014), Edwards A., Leech J. (2014)