Support MycoNote →

MycoNote

Brown birch bolete or Red-capped scaber stalk

How they differ, how to recognize them and which is more dangerous — a mushroom comparison

The short answer

Brown birch bolete and Red-capped scaber stalk are similar species that can be mixed up while foraging. The main visible difference: use: Brown birch bolete — culinary, cook fresh, drying, freezing, Red-capped scaber stalk — culinary, drying, freezing. The mushrooms also differ in the following features: size, cap color, flesh color change.

📊 Comparing characteristics

Comparison of characteristics: Brown birch bolete and Red-capped scaber stalk
Edibility class

Brown birch bolete

Edible

Red-capped scaber stalk

Edible
Season

Brown birch bolete

SummerAutumn

Red-capped scaber stalk

SummerAutumn
Use

Brown birch bolete

CulinaryCook freshDryingFreezing

Red-capped scaber stalk

CulinaryDryingFreezing
Size

Brown birch bolete

Medium (5–15 cm)

Red-capped scaber stalk

Large (over 15 cm)
Cap color

Brown birch bolete

BrownDark brownGrey

Red-capped scaber stalk

OrangeRustyRed
Cap shape

Brown birch bolete

Convex

Red-capped scaber stalk

Convex
Cap surface

Brown birch bolete

DryVelvety

Red-capped scaber stalk

DryVelvety
Taste

Brown birch bolete

Mild

Red-capped scaber stalk

Mild
Smell

Brown birch bolete

Pleasant, mushroomy

Red-capped scaber stalk

Pleasant, mushroomy
Flesh color change

Brown birch bolete

No change

Red-capped scaber stalk

Blackening
Hymenophore

Brown birch bolete

Pored

Red-capped scaber stalk

Pored
Stem

Brown birch bolete

CentralSolid

Red-capped scaber stalk

CentralSolid
Ring (veil)

Brown birch bolete

No ring

Red-capped scaber stalk

No ring
Volva

Brown birch bolete

No volva

Red-capped scaber stalk

No volva
Substrate

Brown birch bolete

Soil

Red-capped scaber stalk

Soil
Nutrition type

Brown birch bolete

Mycorrhizal

Red-capped scaber stalk

Mycorrhizal
Partner trees

Brown birch bolete

Birch

Red-capped scaber stalk

AspenBirch

📅 Seasonality

Brown birch bolete

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

June – October

Red-capped scaber stalk

Fruiting season

Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec

June – October

🔬 Morphology

Cap

Brown birch bolete

Cap 5–15 cm across, at first spherical or hemispherical, later cushion-shaped. The surface is smooth or slightly wrinkled, dry or a little sticky in wet weather. Color ranges from grayish brown to dark brown, more rarely almost black.

Red-capped scaber stalk

Cap 6–20 cm across, spherical in young mushrooms, then cushion-shaped. The surface is finely felted or slightly leathery, dry. The color is vivid — brick-red, orange or ginger; in shady spots it may be duller.

Hymenophore

Brown birch bolete

The hymenophore is tubular. The tubes and pores are white, small in young mushrooms and wider in mature ones. When pressed, the pores turn slightly brownish, but there's never any bluing: unlike in the red-capped scaber stalks, the flesh doesn't blue even at the stem base.

Red-capped scaber stalk

The hymenophore has tubes. Pores small, round, white at first, then turning brownish. When pressed, the pores turn brownish — this is a normal reaction and does not indicate danger.

Stem

Brown birch bolete

Stem 8–18 cm tall, 1.5–3 cm thick, cylindrical, fairly long and slender compared with the cap. The surface is white or grayish, densely covered with dark, fibrous scales — the hallmark of the genus Leccinum. The stem is firm and fibrous.

Red-capped scaber stalk

Stem 8–20 cm tall, 2–4 cm thick, firm, club-shaped at the bottom, cylindrical in the upper part. The surface is white, covered with scales and fibres: reddish, sometimes whitish, in young mushrooms, turning red-brown to blackish with age. The stem base often shows a blue tint, especially where it has been handled. The stem is very hard, almost woody in mature mushrooms.

Flesh

Brown birch bolete

The flesh is firm and white; when cut it doesn't change colour or turns slightly pinkish, and after a few hours may become a little greyish or brownish. It darkens to grey-black only when cooked. The taste is mild and neutral. The cap skin doesn't peel.

Red-capped scaber stalk

Flesh firm, white; when cut it darkens to violet-grey, grey and eventually almost black; only the stem base often turns blue-green. The darkening also happens during cooking. The taste is pleasant, meaty. In mature mushrooms the stem is very fibrous.

Smell

Brown birch bolete

The smell is unobtrusive, pleasant and typically mushroomy. The aroma intensifies with cooking. When dried, the brown birch bolete takes on a rich scent that falls short of porcini but is noticeably better than most other pored mushrooms.

Red-capped scaber stalk

Smell faint, pleasant, mushroomy, slightly earthy. When fried, the aroma becomes richer and more appetizing. Compared with porcini, the red-capped scaber stalk's smell is less pronounced, but quite pleasant.

📍 Habitats

Brown birch bolete

Deciduous forestMixed forest

Red-capped scaber stalk

Deciduous forestMixed forest

👀 Similar mushrooms — don't mix them up!

❓ Frequently asked questions

Can Brown birch bolete and Red-capped scaber stalk be mixed up?
Yes, they look so similar that people often mix them up. The use, size, cap color help tell them apart.
How to tell Brown birch bolete from Red-capped scaber stalk?
The main differences: use: Brown birch bolete — culinary, cook fresh, drying, freezing, Red-capped scaber stalk — culinary, drying, freezing; size: Brown birch bolete — medium (5–15 cm), Red-capped scaber stalk — large (over 15 cm); cap color: Brown birch bolete — brown, dark brown, grey, Red-capped scaber stalk — orange, rusty, red. The full table of characteristics is higher up on this page.
Is Red-capped scaber stalk edible?
Red-capped scaber stalk — edible.
When do Brown birch bolete and Red-capped scaber stalk grow?
Brown birch bolete — June–October; Red-capped scaber stalk — June–October. Their seasons overlap, so be especially careful.

Sources

  • [1]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [2]GBIF