Photo: Pethan at Dutch Wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Photo: Pethan at Dutch Wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Black bulgarBulgaria inquinans
Passport
- Hymenophore
- Smooth
- Cap colour
- Black
- Size
- Small (up to 5 cm)
Inedible
Most often confused with: King Alfred's cakes (inedible).
Quick answers
Where to look?
When does it appear? Europe
How to recognise it? Three signs
- Cap colour: Black, Dark brown
- Cap shape: Depressed
- Smell: Odourless
Description
The black bulgar (Bulgaria inquinans) is a small, rubbery, almost black fungus that grows in dense groups on felled oak trunks and fallen branches. It looks like a jelly fungus, but it's an ascomycete. Young ones resemble black buttons or drops of resin, and older ones open into shallow cups with a shiny black top and a rough, dark brown outside. It isn't one for the basket.
Is black bulgar edible?
No. Field guides list it as inedible, and it may contain toxins. In the Changbai mountains of northeast China some people do eat it, but only after special treatment. Without that treatment it has caused a swollen mouth and burning skin in sunlight, and researchers reproduced the sun sensitivity in mice. We advise against eating it in any form.
Don't mix it up with the "black fungus" sold for cooking. That's a wood ear (Auricularia), a relative of the jelly ear, and a very different fungus.
Bulgaria inquinans identification
Look on oak first, usually wood that's still fairly fresh with the bark on, and less often on beech, sweet chestnut, ash or hornbeam. It appears in autumn and carries on through winter, into early spring in mild areas.
Run a finger over the top of a mature cup and it comes away dark with spores, which is why it's called inquinans, "staining". Witches' butter (Exidia glandulosa) is the usual lookalike, but it's much softer, with a surface of tiny bumps, no neat cup shape and a sparse white spore print, so it won't mark your fingers.
Across Europe
Found across mainland Europe on felled oaks, sweet chestnut and beech, and less often on ash. In Germany it is Gemeiner Schmutzbecherling, in France bulgarie salissante, in Sweden limsvamp and in the Netherlands zwarte knoopzwam.
Cap
Fruiting bodies usually 1–4 cm across, occasionally as small as 0.5 cm, and about 1 cm tall or a little more. Young ones are rounded and closed, like black buttons or drops of resin; with age they open into shallow cups or discs. The outside is dark brown and rough; the inside (where the hymenium is) is smooth, black and shiny.
Hymenophore
Smooth, forming the shiny black upper surface of the cup. The spore print is very dark brown, almost black, and the spores are what stain your fingers. Spores 11–14 × 6–7 µm, smooth. Only the upper four in each ascus are dark brown; the lower four are colourless and much smaller.
Stem
Practically no stem. The fruiting body is sessile, attached to the wood by a broad base.
Flesh
Flesh dark ochre-brown, soft and rubbery in wet weather, tougher and more elastic when dry. Doesn't change colour when cut.
Smell
No distinct smell. Taste indistinct; we don't taste it, since the mushroom is inedible.
›Scientific synonyms (1)
Peziza inquinans Pers. (1794)
Don’t mix them up
Black bulgar lookalikes and comparison
Compare with another mushroom| Feature | Black bulgar | King Alfred's cakes |
|---|---|---|
| Hymenophore | Smooth | — |
| Cap colour | Black, Dark brown | Black, Dark brown, Brown |
| Smell | Odourless | — |
| Edibility | Inedible | Inedible |
Other lookalikes
Witches' butterInediblecomparison →
Readers’ finds · 0
Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.
Related species
Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Jelly ear
Auricularia auricula-judae

Hooded false morel
Paragyromitra infula

Devil's urn
Urnula craterium

Yellow brain
Tremella mesenterica

Hairy curtain crust
Stereum hirsutum

Discina ancilis

Horn of plenty
Craterellus cornucopioides

Crested coral
Clavulina coralloides
Frequently asked questions
Can you eat it?
No. The black bulgar is inedible and has no culinary value at all. Eaten without special treatment, this species has caused a swollen mouth and burning skin in sunlight, so it's better not to take the risk.
Is it dangerous just to touch it?
No, it's safe to touch. The black spore powder washes off your hands easily with water: it's just spores, not a toxin. If you have sensitive skin, though, wash your hands afterwards.
Where should you look for it?
On felled trunks and fallen branches of broadleaf trees, above all oak, and less often beech, sweet chestnut, ash and hornbeam. The wood is often still fairly fresh, with the bark on.
Where does it grow in Europe?
It's fairly common across Europe, wherever there's felled or fallen oak, and it also grows on other broadleaf trees.
When does it appear?
From autumn through winter, and into early spring in mild areas. It's easy to spot after the first night frosts, when most other mushrooms have gone.
Can it overwinter on the trunk?
Yes. The dried black cups often stay on the wood until spring, hard as a lacquered crust. Rain soaks them back up, and you can see them releasing spores even in spring.
What is it confused with?
With Exidia glandulosa ("witches' butter"), a black jelly fungus that also grows on rotting deciduous wood. The difference: Exidia is jelly-soft, has no clear cup shape and doesn't puff black powder when touched.
Nothing to do with truffles, then?
No. Truffles grow underground, are rounded with no cup, and smell completely different. The black bulgar is always on wood, flat or cup-shaped, and has no aroma at all.
What is a black bulgar?
It's a small, rubbery, almost black fungus that grows in groups on felled oak and other broadleaf wood. It looks like a jelly fungus but belongs to the ascomycetes, and it's inedible.
Is black bulgar the same as black fungus?
No. The black fungus sold for cooking is a wood ear (Auricularia), which is a very different fungus. The black bulgar is inedible, so don't treat it as a wild source of wood ear.
Why does the black bulgar stain your fingers?
Its dark spores rub off the top of mature cups and mark your skin. That's where the Latin name inquinans, meaning polluting or staining, comes from.
Sources
- [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
- [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
- [3]MycoBank Database
- [4]Index Fungorum
- [5]GBIF
- [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
- [7]First Nature: Bulgaria inquinans, Black Bulgar
- [8]Bao H.-Y., Li Z.-J., Yang S.-D. et al. Photosensitive toxic components of Bulgaria inquinans. Mycosystema, 2019, 38(1): 117–126, Bao H.-Y., Li Z.-J., Yang S.-D. et al. (2019)
- [9]Wikipedia (de): Gemeiner Schmutzbecherling
- [10]Wikipedia (en): Bulgaria inquinans
- [11]First Nature: Exidia glandulosa, Witches' Butter