Support MycoNote →

MycoNote
Want to find

Photo: Holger Krisp · CC BY 3.0 · source

Conditionally edible✓ Checked by an expert

Butter capRhodocollybia butyracea

SeasonSeptember – December

Passport

Hymenophore
Gilled
Cap colour
Brown
Size
Small (up to 5 cm)

✓ Conditionally edible

Most often confused with: Wood pinkgill (poisonous).

Quick answers

When does it appear? Europe

Sep — Dec

Active months: September, October, November, December.

How to recognise it? Three signs

Description

The butter cap, also written buttercap (Rhodocollybia butyracea, formerly Collybia butyracea), is a brown woodland mushroom whose cap looks and feels greasy, as if smeared with butter, especially in wet weather. It fruits in leaf and needle litter. It is edible, but a poor one: the cap is bland and the stem is tough.

Conditionally edible: young fruiting bodies can be cooked after a short boil. The flesh is fairly tender and neutral in taste, but its culinary value is low. People rarely gather it for its own sake; it goes into a mix with genuinely tasty mushrooms (honey fungus, slippery jacks) as a "filler". Old Soviet literature lists it as "edible, category 4"; today the advice is to boil it for 10 min first to be safe.

What stands out is its very long fruiting season: summer to late autumn, and in some years right up to the first frosts. It often appears in large numbers in late autumn, when most of the tasty mushrooms are already gone. It's a saprotroph of conifer and broadleaf litter.

Don't confuse it with the spotted toughshank (R. maculata), which is usually a little larger, with characteristic rusty spots on a white cap and a bitterish taste. Don't confuse it with Gymnopus dryophilus (russet toughshank) either: it has a thinner reddish stem and a cap without a greasy sheen.

In Ukraine the butter cap is common throughout the forest zone, from mountain and foothill forests to lowland woods and the forest-steppe. In the steppe it turns up in planted shelterbelts and ravine (bairak) woods. It often grows in groups of 5-20 fruiting bodies on conifer or broadleaf litter.

How to recognise a buttercap mushroom

Look for a greasy-feeling cap with a paler edge, crowded whitish gills and a tough stem that swells into a club at the base. The cap colour varies a lot, from dark reddish brown to yellowish or pale grey, and it fades as it dries out.

The spore print is pale: white, cream-buff or faintly pink. It grows on the ground in leaf or needle litter, often in groups, not on wood.

Collybia butyracea and other names

Collybia butyracea is the older name of the butter cap, and many field guides kept using it until quite recently. Today it sits in the genus Rhodocollybia.

In the US it is known as the buttery collybia.

Is the butter cap edible?

Yes, but it is a poor edible. Guides describe the taste as poor and the stems as tough, though some people find the caps acceptable.

Our 'conditionally edible' label follows older Ukrainian and Soviet guides, which advise boiling it for 10 minutes first. If you are not sure of every feature, including the pale spore print, leave it.

Where and when it grows

It grows in needle and leaf litter, mainly under conifers but also in broadleaved woodland.

Most finds come from late summer into early winter, so it often keeps appearing after other woodland mushrooms have finished.

Across Europe

Very common and widespread throughout mainland Europe, mainly under conifers on needles and leaf litter. The butter returns in German Butter-Rübling, Dutch botercollybia and French collybie beurrée.

Brown and grey forms

Some authorities split the butter cap into two varieties by colour. Besides the usual brown form there is var. asema, which has a dark grey centre to the cap.

Both share the greasy cap, the club-shaped stem and the pale spore print, so colour alone is a weak guide.

Cap

The cap is 3-7 cm across, convex when young, opening out with age to flat with a small umbo in the centre (a characteristic shape). The cap skin is smooth, with a pronounced buttery-greasy sheen in wet weather, hence the name. It's strongly hygrophanous: in wet weather dark chestnut-brown in the centre and lighter toward the margin; when dry, light creamy brown to ochre and faded. The margin is even and thin, often with lengthwise striations where the gills show through.

Hymenophore

The gills are adnate or free from the stem, crowded, thin, whitish to cream, turning cream-pink with age. The spore print is pale pink to cream, a typical trait of the genus Rhodocollybia ("pink Collybia").

Stem

The stem is 3-7 cm tall and 0.3-0.8 cm thick, cylindrical and noticeably thickening toward the base (often with a characteristic "root" running down into the substrate). It's ochre-brownish, darker toward the base, with a smooth surface and lengthwise fibres. The stem flesh is tougher and more fibrous than the cap's.

Flesh

The flesh is thin and tender in the cap, tough and fibrous in the stem, whitish to cream, and it doesn't change colour when cut. The smell is faintly mushroomy, the taste mild and neutral, normally without bitterness.

Smell

Faint, neutral, mushroomy, nothing distinctive.

›Scientific synonyms (1)

Collybia butyracea (Bull.) P.Kumm.

Don’t mix them up

Butter cap lookalikes and comparison

FeatureButter capWood pinkgill
HymenophoreGilledGilled
Cap colourBrown, CreamGrey, Brown, Cream, Olive
SmellOdourlessOdourless, Floury, Chemical
EdibilityConditionally ediblePoisonous
Full comparison: Butter cap vs Wood pinkgill →
Compare with another mushroom

Readers’ finds · 0

Readers’ photos aren’t checked by an expert. “Confirmed” means foragers in the feed agree — not a guarantee. When in doubt, leave it.

Your find

Butter capchange

…

Mushrooms of the same genus and habitat — to study side by side and never mix up.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth picking?

You can, but don't expect much. Its culinary value is low: the taste is neutral and the stem flesh is tough. Mixed with more aromatic mushrooms (honey fungus, slippery jacks), it's fine; on its own, it's dull. If you find it late in autumn, when other mushrooms are already gone, it's an option.

How do you tell it apart from similar species?

Key features of R. butyracea: (1) a buttery, greasy sheen on the cap in wet weather; (2) strong hygrophaneity, so it turns light ochre as it dries; (3) a stem that thickens toward the base into a "root"; (4) a pale cream to pinkish spore print; (5) a mild, neutral taste. R. maculata has rusty spots and tastes bitter. The russet toughshank has no greasy sheen and a thinner stem.

How should you cook it?

Take young fruiting bodies, boil them for 10 min first and drain the water. Then fry them with onions, stew them or add them to soup. Pickling is fine too. Drying doesn't work well, as the flesh loses its flavour. Old fruiting bodies with dark caps aren't worth it: the flesh turns limp and woody.

Where should you look for it?

On conifer and broadleaf litter in pine, spruce, mixed spruce-broadleaf, beech and oak forests. It loves damp, shaded spots with a thick layer of forest litter. It often grows in groups of 5-20 fruiting bodies.

Where in Europe is it found?

Very common throughout Europe. In Ukraine it is common throughout the forest zone, from mountain and foothill forests to lowland woods and the forest-steppe. In the steppe — in planted shelterbelts and ravine (bairak) forests.

When should you look for it?

It has one of the longest seasons of any species: summer to late autumn. In warm autumns it keeps going until the first frosts. That's its real value: it appears when other mushrooms are already gone.

What mushrooms is it confused with?

With R. maculata (spotted toughshank), which is larger, with rusty spots on a white cap, and bitter. With Gymnopus dryophilus (russet toughshank), which has no greasy sheen and a thinner reddish stem. With Mycena galericulata (common bonnet), which is smaller, grows on wood and has a thinner stem. With Clitocybe vibecina, which smells of flour (the butter cap has no such smell). The dangerous mix-up is the poisonous wood pinkgill (Entoloma rhodopolium): it has no greasy sheen, no swollen stem base, and its gills turn pink with age.

Is it different from "honey fungus"?

Yes. The butter cap grows on soil and litter, while honey fungus (Armillaria) grows on wood (stumps, roots). Most honey fungus species have a ring on the stem (the ringless honey fungus is the exception); the butter cap never has one. Honey fungus leaves a white spore print, the butter cap a pale cream to pinkish one.

Sources

  • [1]Вікіпедія (українська)
  • [2]Атлас грибів України, Зеров Д.К. (1979)
  • [3]MycoBank Database
  • [4]Index Fungorum
  • [5]GBIF
  • [6]iNaturalist Ukraine
  • [7]Rhodocollybia butyracea, Butter Cap mushroom, Pat O'Reilly
  • [8]Butter Cap, Wild Food UK
  • [9]Rhodocollybia butyracea (Butter Cap), NatureSpot